Microsoft Word - behavioural extiction methods for sleep position statement.docx

Australian Association for Infant Mental Health Limited

44 Fullarton Rd, Norwood SA 5067 | ABN 88 625 753 522| ACN 625 753 522 info@aaimh.org.au |

www.aaimh.org.au

Infant Sleep

!"#$%&"$$'()&*+,(-.(#&/00/1&2(,"$()&34#56&/0071&85%+.(#&/09:1&34#56&/0//;&

Purpose of AAIMH

The$Australian$Association$for$Infant$Mental$Health$Ltd$(AAIMH)$is$a$not-for-profit$

organisation$of$professionals$from$a$range$of$disciplines$including$health,$education$

and$welfare$dedicated$to$the$field$of$infant$mental$health.$<<=3>?$&-"$$"+@&"$&%+&A+#B&

C+#& 4DD& "@C4@%$& 4@)& E+'@F& 56"D)#(@& C#+-& G#(& ."#%6& %+& 4F(& %6#((& %+& (@$'#(& %6("#& $+5"4DH&

(-+%"+@4DH&4@)&)(,(D+G-(@%4D&@(()$&4#(&-(%&%6#+'F6& $%4.D(&4@)&@'#%'#"@F&#(D4%"+@$6"G$&

A"%6"@& %6("#& C4-"DEH& 5'D%'#(H& 4@)& 5+--'@"%"($;& I6"$& "$& 456"(,()& .E& 4$$"$%"@F& C4-"D"($H&

G#+C($$"+@4D$H& 4@)& 5+--'@"%"($& %+& .'"D)& @'#%'#"@F& 4@)& $%#+@F& #(D4%"+@$6"G$& A"%6& %6("#&

56"D)#(@H&4@)&%+&.(&4A4#(&+C&%6(&54'$($&4@)&$"F@$&+C&-(@%4DH&G6E$"54DH&4@)&(-+%"+@4D&$%#($$&

"@&"@C4@%$;&

Definitions

Infant&Sleep&

JD((G& "$& 4& 5+-GD(K& @('#+.(64,"+'#4D& $%4%(& 4@)& $D((G& .(64,"+'#& -'$%& .(& ,"(A()& A"%6"@& 4&

."+G$E56+$+5"4D& C#4-(A+#B& LM(@@"& N& O4#$B4)+@H& /00PQ;& & R6"D(& ."+D+F"54D& G#+5($$($& 4#(&

)+-"@4@%H&"@C4@%&$D((G&"$&-+$%&(CC(5%",(DE&5+@5(G%'4D"$()&4$&4&5+-GD(K&4)4G%",(&$E$%(-H&"@&

A6"56& %6(#(& "$& 4& 5+@$%4@%DE& (,+D,"@F& "@%(#GD4E& .(%A((@& 5'D%'#4DH& G$E56+$+5"4DH&

%(-G(#4-(@%4DH&(@,"#+@-(@%4D&4@)&."+D+F"54D&C45%+#$&LS+'FD4$H&>"DDH&N&T#+)#"..H&/0991&M(@@"&

N&8UO+@@+#H&/00VQ;&&

I6(#(&4#(&%A+& $D((G& #(F'D4%"@F& -(564@"$-$& "@&%6(& 6'-4@& .+)E;& I6(& C"#$%&"$& %6(& 5"#54)"4@&

#6E%6-H& 4D$+& B@+A@& 4$& %6(& .+)E& 5D+5B;& I6(& 5"#54)"4@& #6E%6-& #(F'D4%($& G6E$"+D+F"54DH&

.(64,"+'#4DH&4@)&-(%4.+D"5&$%4%($H&"@5D')"@F&%6(&$D((G&A4B(& 5E5D(&%6#+'F6+'%&%6(&/7W6+'#&

)4E;&*(A.+#@&"@C4@%$&)+&@+%&)(-+@$%#4%(&4&5"#54)"4@&#6E%6-&%+&%6("#&$D((G&A4B(&5E5D(&4%&

."#%6;& >+A(,(#H& 4& 5"#54)"4@& G4%%(#@& (-(#F($& "@& %6(& C"#$%& C(A& -+@%6$& +C& D"C(H& #(F'D4%()& .E&

(KG+$'#(& %+& D"F6%H& @+"$(H& 45%","%E& 4@)& $+5"4D& 5'($& LM(@@"& N& O4#$B4)+@H& /00PQ;& & I6(& $(5+@)&

#(F'D4%"@F&-(564@"$-&"$&B@+A@&4$&6+-(+$%4%"5&G#($$'#(;&I6(&@(()&%+&$D((G&L$D((G&G#($$'#(Q&

"@5#(4$($&4$&%6(&)'#4%"+@&+C&A4B(C'D@($$&"@5#(4$($H&4@)&%6(&E+'@F(#&%6(&"@C4@%H&%6(&D($$&%"-(&

%6(E&54@&-4@4F(&4A4B(&LM(@@"&N&O4#$B4)+@H&/00P Q;&&&

=@C4@%$& 64,(& )"CC(#(@%& $D((G& 5E5D($& C#+-& 4)'D%$;& I6(E& 64,(& $6+#%(#& $D((G& 5E5D($H& F(@(#4DDE&

D4$%"@F& .(%A((@& 7VWX0& -"@'%($;& & I6(& "@C4@%?$& $D((G& 5E5D(& "$& 564#45%(#"$()& .E& 4D%(#4%"+@$&

.(%A((@& #4G")& (E(& -+,(-(@%& L2Y3Q& $D((G& 4@)& @+@W#4G")& (E(& -+,(-(@%& $D((G& L*2Y3Q;&

S'#"@F&2Y3H&.#4"@&F#+A%6&4@)&)"CC(#(@%"4%"+@&+C&@('#+@4D&G4%6A4E$&+55'#H&A6"D(&"@&*2Y3&

Page 2 of 13

#($%&+55'#$H&A"%6&+#F4@"$4%"+@&+C&%6(&"@C4@%?$&"--4%'#(&@(#,+'$&$E$%(-;&I6(&"@C4@%&$G(@)$&4&

F#(4%(#&4-+'@%&+C&%"-(&"@&2Y3&$D((G&5+-G4#()&%+&56"D)#(@&4@)&4)'D%$H&A6(#(&$D((G&"$&D"F6%H&

4@)&%6(&"@C4@%&"$&-+#(&(4$"DE&)"$%'#.();&I6"$&54@&54'$(&%6(-&%+&4#+'$(ZA4B(@&-+#(&+C%(@&"@&

%6(&@"F6%&L34#($H&*(A-4@H&N&R4##(@H&/09/Q;&&I6(E&-4E&4D$+&.(&6'@F#E&4@)&@(()&C(()"@F&4$&

%6(E&64,(&$-4DD&$%+-456$;&I6(#(C+#(H& "%&"$&@+#-4D&C+#& "@C4@%$& 4@)&E+'@F&56"D)#(@& %+& A4B(&

%6#+'F6&%6(&@"F6%&4@)&%+&@(()&4%%(@%"+@&C#+-&G4#(@%$&+#&54#(F",(#$;&I6(#(&"$&4&A")(&,4#"4%"+@&

"@&%6(&4F(&4%&A6"56&"@C4@%$&4@)&%+))D(#$&[$D((G&%6#+'F6&%6(&@"F6%H?&8@&4,(#4F(H&\:]&+C&"@C4@%$&

4%&%6#((&-+@%6$H&4@)&PP;P]&+C&"@C4@%$&4%&("F6%&-+@%6$&$%"DD&#(^'"#(&$'GG+#%&%+&$(%%D(&)'#"@F&

%6(&@"F6%&L_44,+@(@&(%&4D;H&/0/0Q;&&

Crying&

<&$"F@4D&+C&)"$%#($$&+#&)"$5+-C+#%&L("%6(#&G$E56+D+F"54D&+#&G6E$"54DQ&C#+-&4@&"@C4@%&+#&E+'@F&

56"D)&%+&D(%&%6(&54#(F",(#&B@+A& %64%&%6(E&@(()&6(DG;&!#+-&4@&(,+ D'%"+@4#E&G(#$G(5%",(H&5#E"@F&

G#+-+%($&G#+K"-"%E&%+&%6(&G#"-4#E&54#(F",(#H&"@&%6(& "@%(#($%&+C&$'#,",4D& 4@)&%6(&)(,(D+G-(@%&

+C&$+5"4D&.+@)$&LT+AD.EH&9`V\Q;&

Sleep&problems&

O'##(@%DEH&.(%A((@&/VW70]&+C&C4-"D"($&#(G+#%&$D((G&G#+.D(-$&"@&"@C4@5E&4@)&(4#DE&56"D)6++)H&

-+$%&+C%(@&)($5#".()&4$&)(D4E()&$D((GH&C#(^'(@%&@"F6%&A4B"@F$&+#&"@4."D"%E&%+&#(%'#@&%+&$D((G&

A"%6+'%&G4#(@%4D&G#($(@5(&L_44,+@(@&(%&4D;H&/0/01&_#"5(&(%&4D;H&/0971&J4)(6H&3"@)(DDH&a'()%B(H&

N&R"(F4@)H&/00`Q;&&>+A(,(#&5D"@"54DDEH&"@C4@%&$D((G&"$&+C%(@&+@DE&,"(A()&4$&4&G#+.D(-&"C&%6(&

G4#(@%Z54#(#& G(#5(",($& "%& 4$& 4& G#+.D(-& LT4##H& 9``:Q;& & _#+D+@F()& $D((G& G#+.D(-$& 54@&

@(F4%",(DE&"-G45%&4&56"D)?$&5+F@"%",(&)(,(D+G-(@%H&-++)&#(F'D4%"+@H&.(64,"+'#&4@)&G6E$"54D&

6(4D%6& L3"@)(DDH& b'6@H& a(A"@H& 3(D%c(#H& N& J4)(6H& /00XQ;&&_4#(@%& 4@)& 54#(F",(#& $D((G& 4@)&

A(DD.("@F&4#(&4D$+&"-G45%()H&A"%6&+@F+"@F&#()'5()&$D((G&4$$+5"4%()&A"%6&"@5#(4$()&C((D"@F$&

+C& $%#($$H& 4@K"(%EH& )(G#($$"+@& 4@)& G(#5(",()& 4."D"%E& %+& 5+G(& LY%6(#%+@H& TD'@)(@H& N& >4'5BH&

/09XQ;&&&=@&-+#(&(K%#(-(&(K4-GD($H&"%&54@&5+@%#".'%(&%+&56"D)&4.'$(&LM4-($W2+.(#%$H&/00PQ;&&&

=@C4@%$&4@)&E+'@F&56"D)#(@&A6+&A4B(& +C%(@H&)+&@+%&$(%%D(&(4$"DEH&+#&)+&@+%&$D((G&%6#+'F6&%6(&

@"F6%&4#(&$+-(%"-($&$4")&%+&64,(&sleep&problems;&S"CC(#(@5($&"@&"@C4@%&$D((G&G4%%(#@$&-4E&.(&

"@CD'(@5()&.E&4&@'-.(#&+C&C45%+#$&"@5D')"@Fd&

• =@C4@%&%(-G(#4-(@%&

• S(,(D+G-(@%&G#+5($$($&

• =@C4@%&C(()"@F&G#45%"5($&

• _4#(@%4DZ54#(#&(KG(5%4%"+@$&#(D4%()&%+&"@C4@%&5#E"@F&4@)&$D((G&&

• _4#(@%"@F&G6"D+$+G6"($&+#&G#45%"5($&

• !4-"DE&#(D4%"+@4D&)E@4-"5$&&

• _$E56+$+5"4D&C45%+#$&"@5D')"@F&564@F($&"@&%6(&54#(&F","@F&(@,"#+@-(@%&

• =@C4@%&6(4D%6&"$$'($&&&

• _4#(@%4DZ54#(#&6(4D%6&"$$'($H&"@5D')"@F&G6E$"54D&4@)&-(@%4D&6(4D%6&5+@5(#@$&

• _6E$"54D&$D((G"@F&4##4@F(-(@%$&"@5D')"@F&"@C4@%$&.()&$64#"@FH&$D((G"@F&"@&4&$(G4#4%(&.()&

4@)Z+#&#++-&C#+-&G4#(@%$&+#&54#(#$&&

• S(,(D+G-(@%4D&G#+.D(-$&

Page 3 of 13

Extinction&Based&Behavioural&Sleep&Interventions&&

YK%"@5%"+@&T4$()&T(64,"+'#4D&JD((G&=@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&.4$()&+@&JB"@@(#?$&.(64,"+'#"$%&%6(+#E&

+C&+G(#4@%&5+@)"%"+@"@F&"@&D(4#@()&.(64,"+'#&LJB"@@(#H&9`\7Q;&&R"%6&"@C4@%&$D((G&G#+.D(-$H&

%6(& G4#(@%& +#& 54#(#?$& 4%%(@%"+@& "$& G(#5(",()& %+& #("@C+#5(& %6(& "@C4@%?$& 5#E"@F;& I6(#(C+#(H&

(K%"@5%"+@&-(%6+)$&4"-&%+&"-G#+,(&"@C4@%&$D((G&.E&#(-+,"@FZ#()'5"@F&54#(F",(#&4%%(@%"+@&

)'#"@F&$D((G&%"-($&%+&(D"-"@4%(&5#E"@FH&A"%6&%6(&,"(A&%64%&%6"$&A"DD&(@5+'#4F(&%6(&"@C4@%&%+&

$(DCW$(%%D(&L>"$5+5B&N&S4,(EH&/09\Q;&I6(&-+$%&5+--+@&(K%"@5%"+@&-(%6+)$&#(G+#%()&"@&%6(&

D"%(#4%'#(& 4#(& '@-+)"C"()& (K%"@5%"+@H& (K%"@5%"+@& A"%6& 54#(F",(#& G#($(@5(& 4@)& F#4)'4%()&

(K%"@5%"+@;&<DD&+C&%6($(&-(%6+)$&"@,+D,(H&%+&$+-(&(K%(@%H&"F@+#"@F&%6(&"@C4@%?$&5#E"@F&+@5(&$6(&

64$& .((@& G'%& %+& .();& & =C& %6(#(&4#(& "@%(#45%"+@$H&%6(E& 4#(& .#"(C& 4@)& "@,+D,(& D"-"%()& $(%%D"@F&

$'GG+#%;&I4.D(&9&G#($(@%$&4&$'--4#E&+C&%6($(&-(%6+)$;&&

I4.D(&9;&

Intervention$Name$

Colloquial$Name$

Procedure$Summary$

Unmodified$

extinction$

O#E&"%&+'%&

O6"D)&"$&G'%&%+&.()&4@)&"F@+#()&'@%"D&4&$(%&

A4B(&%"-(&

Graduated$

extinction$

O+@%#+DD()&

5+-C+#%"@FH&

5+@%#+DD()&5#E"@FH&

$D((G&%#4"@"@F&

54#(F",(#$&"F@+#(&%6(&56"D)?$&5#E"@F&C+#&$(%&

G(#"+)$&+C&%"-(&.(C+#(&#(%'#@"@F&%+&$(%%D(&

L'$"@F&D"-"%()&%(56@"^'($Q&4@)&#(G(4%"@F&

'@%"D&%6(&"@C4@%&$D((G$;&34E&'$(&4&C"K()&$54D(&

L(;F;H&(,(#E&V-"@Q&+#&4@&"@5#(-(@%4D&$54D(&

L(;F;H/H&7H&X-"@Q&

Extinction$with$

caregiver$presence$

O4#(F",(#&G#($(@5(H&

54-G"@F&+'%&

O4#(F",(#&"F@+#($&%6(&56"D)?$&5#E"@F&.'%&

#(-4"@$&@(4#&%6(&56"D)&"@&%6(&#++-&'@%"D&

%6(E&C4DD&4$D((G&+CC(#"@F&D"-"%()&$(%%D"@F&

%(56@"^'($;&I6(&54#(F",(#&F#4)'4DDE&

"@5#(4$($&%6(&G6E$"54D&)"$%4@5(&C#+-&%6(&

56"D)&&

<)4G%()&C#+-&Y%6(#%+@H&TD'@)(@H&N&>4'5BH&/09X&

Extinction Based Behavioral Sleep Intervention Research:

YK%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&.E&C4#&%6(&-+$%&5+--+@&"@%(#,(@%"+@&

"@&"@C4@%&$D((G&#($(4#56H&A"%6&\9]&+C&4DD&"@C4@%&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@&D"%(#4%'#(&C+5'$()&+@&%6($(&

4GG#+456($&LY%6(#%+@&(%&4D;H&/09XQ;&&*+%4.DEH&X9]&+C&$D((G&4),"5(&.++B$&4"-()&4%&54#(F",(#$&

(@)+#$(& (K%"@5%"+@& .4$()& 4GG#+456($& L24-+$& N& e+'@F5D4#B(H& /00XQ;& & S($G"%(& %6"$H& %6(#(&

#(-4"@$& F#(4%& ,4#"4%"+@& 4@)& 5+@%#+,(#$E& "@& %6(& C"@)"@F$& 4.+'%& %6(& (CC"545E& +C& %6($(&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$;&&

J(,(#4D&$E$%(-4%"5&#(,"(A$& 4@)& -(%4W4@4DE$($& 64,(& .((@& 5+@)'5%()&+@& .(64,"+'#4D& $D((G&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$H&"@5D')"@F& (K%"@5%"+@& .4$()& $%#4%(F"($& LT#E4@%+@H& T(5BH& N& 3+@%(DG4#(H& /09:1&

S+'FD4$&N&>"DDH&/09:1&b(-GD(#H&J64#G(H&3"DD(#H&N&T4#%D(%%H&/09XQ;&<DD&+C&%6($(&#(,"(A$&,4#E&"@&

%6("#& 5+@5D'$"+@$H& #(CD(5%"@F& -(%6+)+D+F"54D& 5+@5(#@$H& ,4#"4%"+@$& "@& +'%5+-(& -(4$'#($H&

G+$$".D(& "@%(#G#(%4%"+@& ."4$H& %6(& -'D%"5+-G+@(@%& @4%'#(& +C& -4@E& "@%(#,(@%"+@$H& 4@)& %6(&

Page 4 of 13

5+-GD(K"%E&+C&"@C4@%&$D((G&5+@5(#@$;&&I6+$(&#(,"(A$&%64%&)+&5+@5D')(&.(@(C"%H&$'FF($%&%64%&4@E&

"@5#(4$(&"@&-4%(#@4D&#(G+#%()&"@C4@%&$D((G&%"-(&"$&$-4DD&%+&-+)(#4%(&4@)&"$&'@D"B(DE&%+&#()'5(&

%6(&@'-.(#&+C&@"F6%&A4B($;&I6(#(&"$&4D$+&"@)"54%"+@&%64%&%6(#(&-4E&.(&4@&"-G#+,(-(@%&"@&

-4%(#@4D&-++)H&.'%&4F4"@&%6"$&C"@)"@F&"$&^'($%"[email protected](&F",(@&%6(&-'D%"5+-G+@(@%&@4%'#(&+C&%6(&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$& Lb(-GD(#& (%& 4D;H& /09XQ;& & !+#& (K4-GD(H& "@& +@(& #4@)+-"c()& 5+@%#+DD()& %#"4DH&

-+%6(#$&#4%()&[64,"@F&$+-(+@(&%+&%4DB&%+?&4$&%6(&-+$%&'$(C'D&5+-G+@(@%&+C&%6(&"@%(#,(@%"+@&

L>"$5+5B&(%&4D;H&/097Q;&

O+@5(#@$& 4D$+& #(-4"@& 4.+'%& %6(& D+@F& %(#-& "-GD"54%"+@$& +C& (K%"@5%"+@& .4$()& $D((G&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$H&-4"@DE&%6(&"-G45%&+@&"@C4@%&-(@%4D&6(4D%6&4@)&%6(&54#(F",(#W56"D)&4%%456-(@%&

#(D4%"+@$6"G&LY%6(#%+@&(%&4D;H&/09XQ;&&R6"D(&%6(#(&4#(&$+-(&D+@F(#&%(#-&C+DD+A&'G&$%')"($&%64%&

64,(&4%%(-G%()&%+&4))#($$&%6($(&"$$'($&L3"))D(-"$$H&f#4@F(#H&f+D).(#FH&N&*4%64@$H&/09/1&

_#"5(H& R4B(H& gB+'-'@@(H& N& >"$5+5BH& /09/QH& ^'($%"+@$& 64,(& 4D$+& .((@& #4"$()& 4.+'%& %6(&

-(%6+)+D+F"($&'$()&"@&%6($(&$%')"($&L3"))D(-"$$H&/09:Q;&&

R6"D(&"%&-4E&.(&4#F'()&%64%&&(K%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&64,(&$+-(&

G+$"%",(&(CC(5%H&G4#(@%4D&#(D'5%4@5(&%+&'$(&%6($(&%EG($&+C&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&64$&.((@&B@+A@&C+#&

+,(#&:0&E(4#$&LY%6(#%+@&(%&4D;H&/09XQ;&&<'$%#4D"4@&#($(4#56&$'FF($%$&%64%&@(4#DE&%6#((&^'4#%(#$&

+C&G4#(@%$&("%6(#&56+$(&@+%&%+&'$(&5+@%#+DD()&5#E"@F&+#&$%4#%()&"%&4@)&$%+GG()H&)'(&%+& 5+@5(#@$&

%64%& "%& A+'D)& 64,(& 4@& (-+%"+@4DDE& )(%#"-(@%4D& (CC(5%& +@& %6(& "@C4@%& 4@)Z+#& G4#(@%& LT4"DD$H&

/09:Q;&&I6(&$"F@"C"54@%&G4#(@%4D&#(D'5%4@5(&%+&"-GD(-(@%&(K%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&)'(&%+&5+@5(#@$&%6(E&-4E&.(&%++&%#4'-4%"5&C+#&G4#(@%$&+#&"@C4@%$H&&5+@CD"5%&

A"%6&,"(A$& 4.+'%&G4#(@%"@FH&+#&.(&"-G#45%"54D&LI$(&N&>4DDH&/00\Q;&=@%(#($%"@FDEH&%6+$(&G4#(@%$&

A6+&56+$(&@+%&%+&'$(&5+@%#+DD()&5#E"@F&A(#(&D"B(DE&%+&.(&-+#(&(-+%"+@4DDE&C+5'$()&+@&%6("#&

"@C4@%H&A6(#(&%6+$(&%64%&)")&A(#(&-+#(&D"B(DE&%+&.(&+'%5+-(&C+5'$()&LT4"DD$H&/09:Q;&&R6(@&

G4#(@%$&4#(&+@DE& +CC(#()& (K%"@5%"+@&.4$()& .(64,"+'#4D& $D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4$&4@& +G%"+@& %+&

$'GG+#%& "@C4@%& $D((GH& -4@E& -4E& 56++$(& @+%& %+& '%"D"$(& %6(-H& (,(@& "C& %6(E& 64,(& @+& +%6(#&

$%#4%(F"($& %+& "-G#+,(& $D((GH& -4"@%4"@"@F& )"CC"5'D%"($& 4@)& 5+-G+'@)"@F& #"$B& LTD'@)(@& N&

S4A$+@H&/0/0Q;&

Alternatives to Extinction Based Behavioral Sleep Interventions:

8%6(#& 4GG#+456($& %+& $'GG+#%"@F& "@C4@%& $D((G& 64,(& .((@& D($$& A")(DE& $%')"();& I6(#(& "$&

$'FF($%"+@& "@& %6(& D"%(#4%'#(& %64%& [#($G+@$",(?& $D((G& "@%(#,(@%"+@$& 4#(& 4$$+5"4%()& A"%6&

"-G#+,()& "@C4@%& 4@)& 54#(F",(#& $D((G&&LTD'@)(@& N& S4A$+@H& /0/01& 3($-4@& (%& 4D;H& /09\1&

3"))D(-"$$H&J%(,(@$H&2")FA4EH&35S+@4D)H&N&b+'$$4H&/09P1&3"6(D"5H&3+#4A$B4H&N&!"D'$H&/09P1&

R6"%%"@F64-&N&S+'FD4$H&/097Q;&&>+A(,(#H&%6(#(&"$&@+&5+@$"$%(@%&)(C"@"%"+@&"@&%6(&D"%(#4%'#(&

4$& %+& A64%& 5+@$%"%'%($& 4& #($G+@$(W.4$()& 4GG#+456;& & I6(& -+$%& 5+--+@& %6(-(& "@,+D,($&

#($G+@)"@F&%+&4@&"@C4@%?$&5'($&4%&$D((G&%"-(H&#4%6(#&%64@&"F@+#"@F&+#&)(D4E"@F&#($G+@$($;&I6($(&

4GG#+456($&-4E&.(&C4,+'#()&.E&-4@E&54#(F",(#$&4$&%6(E&4,+")&%6(&G(#5(",()&$%#($$&%+&.+%6&

54#(F",(#&4@)&"@C4@%&A6(@&5#E"@F&+55'#$&C+#&G#+D+@F()&G(#"+)$;&LTD'@)(@&N&S4A$+@H&/0/0Q&&

S($G"%(&%6(&5+-G4#4%",(DE&D"-"%()&#($(4#56H&4@&(,")(@5(&.4$(&"$&(-(#F"@F&%+&$'GG+#%&$'56&

4GG#+456($;&<&-+%6(#?$&(-+%"+@4D&4,4"D4."D"%E&64$&.((@&$6+A@&%+&.(&4$$+5"4%()&A"%6&C(A(#&

@"F6%&A4B"@F$&4@)&4&#()'5%"+@&"@&%6(&@'-.(#&+C&%"-($&4&-+%6(#&64)&%+&#(%'#@&%+&%6("#&"@C4@%&

4%&.()%"-(&LI(%"H&b"-H&34E(#H&N&O+'@%(#-"@(H&/090Q;&&2($(4#56&)(-+@$%#4%"@F&%64%&%(456"@F&

G4#(@%$&%+&'@)(#$%4@)&4@)&#($G+@)&%+&"@C4@%&5'($&.+%6&)'#"@F&%6(&)4E&4@)&@"F6 %&#($'D%$&"@&4@&

"@5#(4$(&"@&%+%4D&"@C4@%&$D((G&%"-(H&"@5D')"@F&A"%6&-+%6(#$&(KG(#"(@5"@F&)(G#($$"+@H&4@K"(%E&

Page 5 of 13

4@)&$%#($$&L3"))D(-"$$&(%&4D;H&/09PQ;&&<&#(5(@%&-(%4W4@4DE$"$&+C&G4#(@%"@F&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&L@+%&

@(5($$4#"DE& $D((G& C+5'$()Q& )(-+@$%#4%()& %64%& %(456"@F& G4#(@%$?& 4%%456-(@%W.4$()&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4"-()& 4%& "@5#(4$"@F& G4#(@%4D& #($G+@$",(@($$& #($'D%()& "@& $"F@"C"54@%DE& .(%%(#&

G4#(@%&#(G+#%()&"@C4@%&$D((G&.(64,"+'#$;&&=@%(#($%"@FDEH&%6(&4'%6+#$&G#+G+$(&%64%&%6(&G#45%"5(&

$%#4%(F"($&+C&4%%456-(@%&.4$()&"@%(#,(@%"+@$H&"@5D')"@F&C45"D"%4%+#&-+)(DD"@FH&,")(+&C(().45B&

4@)&45%",(&(@5+'#4F(-(@%&A(#(&5(@%#4D&%+&%6(&$'55($$&+C& %6(&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&L3"6(D"5&(%&4D;H&

/09PQ;&I6"$&$'GG+#%$&#($(4#56&%64%&$'FF($%$&%64%&A6(@&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4"-()&4%&$'GG+#%"@F&

"@C4@%& $D((G& -+,(& .(E+@)& %6(& C+5'$& +C& #()'5"@F& "@C4@%& 5#E"@FH& %+& 4& .#+4)(#& $%#4%(FE& +C&

$'GG+#%"@F& 54#(F",(#$& 4@)& $%#(@F%6(@"@F& %6(& 54#(F",(#W"@C4@%& #(D4%"+@$6"G& %+& (@64@5(&

G4#(@%"@F&54G45"%EH&%6(E&54@&(@64@5(&G4#(@%4D&A(DD.("@FH&"-G#+,(&$D((GH&4$&A(DD&4$&#()'5(&

"@C4@%&5#E"@F&Lf"DB(#$+@H&T'#B64#)%H&b4%56H&N&>4@$H&/0/01&R6"%%"@F64-&N&S+'FD4$H& /097Q;&&

R6"D(&#($G+@$(&.4$()&&4GG#+456($& %+&$D((G&4#(&5+@$"$%(@%&A"%6&%6(&"@C4@%?$&4%%456-(@%&@(()$H&

"%&"$&"-G+#%4@%&%+&#(5+F@"$(&%64%&%6(#(&"$&@+&(-G"#"54D&(,")(@5(&%+&)(-+@$%#4%(&%6"$&%EG(&+C&

"@%(#,(@%"+@&#($'D%$&"@&$(5'#(&4%%456-(@%&Lh#@i(5H&34%%6(EH&N&*(-(%6H&/090Q;&&&

Further Considerations:

The&Early&Years&as&a&Foundation&for&Lifelong&Health&

I6(&4@%(@4%4D&G(#"+)&4@)&%6(&(4#DE&E(4#$&+C&D"C(&4#(&5#"%"54D&C+#&)(,(D+G-(@%;&I6(&C+'@)4%"+@$&

C+#& D"C(D+@F& 6(4D%6& 4#(& .'"D%& (4#DE;& R64%& 64GG(@$& )'#"@F& %6"$& G(#"+)& 54@& 64,(& $'.$%4@%"4D&

(CC(5%$& +@& .+%6& $6+#%W& 4@)& D+@FW%(#-& +'%5+-($& "@& G6E$"54D& 4@)& -(@%4D& 6(4D%6;& *+& +%6(#&

)(,(D+G-(@%4D&$%4F(&"$&-+#(&6(4,"DE&"@CD'(@5()&.E&%6(&(K%(#@4D&(@,"#+@-(@%H&($G(5"4DDE&%6(&

54#(& F","@F& (@,"#+@-(@%;& e+'@F& 56"D)#(@& D","@F& "@& 4@& (@,"#+@-(@%& A"%6& $(@$"%",(& 4@)&

#($G+@$",(& #(D4%"+@$6"G$H& A6(#(& %6("#& @(()$& 4#(& #(5+F@"$()& 4@)& -(%H& 4#(& -+#(& D"B(DE& %+&

)(,(D+G&A(DDWC'@5%"+@"@F& ."+D+F"54D& $E$%(-$H& "@5D')"@F& .#4"@&5"#5'"%$& %64%& $'GG+#%& G+$"%",(&

)(,(D+G-(@%&4@)&D"C(D+@F&6(4D%6&L*4%"+@4D&J5"(@%"C"5&O+'@5"D&+@&%6(&S(,(D+G"@F&O6"D)&/0/0Q;&&&

Attachment&Relationships&

<%%456-(@%& %6(+#E& 64$& .((@& )($5#".()& "@& G$E56+D+FE& 4$& +@(& +C& %6(& -+$%& #(D(,4@%&

)(,(D+G-(@%4D& 5+@$%#'5%$& (,(#& "@,($%"F4%()& LJ#+'C(H& YF(D4@)H& O4#D$+@H& N& O+DD"@$H& /00VQ;&&

<%%456-(@%& .+@)$& #(C(#& %+& %6(& (-+%"+@4D& 5+@@(5%"+@$& .(%A((@& G(+GD(& "@& "@%"-4%(&

#(D4%"+@$6"G$;&<D%6+'F6&4%%456-(@%$&54@&+55'#&"@&4&,4#"(%E&+C&#(D4%"+@$6"G$H&"@&%6"$&G4G(#&A(&

4#(&C+5'$"@F&+@&%6(&54#(F",(#&W56"D)&#(D4%"+@$6"G&Lj(4@46&N&T+#"$H&/000Q;&&<%%456-(@%&%6(+#E&

"$&C+5'$()&+@&6+A&E+'@F&56"D)#(@?$&(4#DE&#(D4%"+@$6"G$&4CC(5%&%6("#&+@F+"@F&)(,(D+G-(@%;&=@&

"@C4@%$& 4@)& E+'@F& 56"D)#(@H& 4%%456-(@%& "$& 564#45%(#"$()& .E& $G(5"C"5& .(64,"+'#$& $'56& 4$&

G#+K"-"%E&$((B"@FH&5+--'@"54%",(&.(64,"+'#$&4@)&$%4E"@F&5D+$(&%+&%6(&54#(F",(#&A6(@&'G$(%&

+#&%6#(4%(@()&"@&+#)(#&%+&456"(,(&(-+%"+@4D&4@)&G6E$"54D&$4C(%E&Lj(4@46&N&T+#"$H&/000Q;&&&

=@C4@%$& )(,(D+G& G4%%(#@$& +C& 4%%456-(@%& "@& #(D4%"+@& %+& %6(& 564#45%(#"$%"5$& +C& %6(& 54#(#?$&

#($G+@$(H& 4@)& "@C4@%$& 64,(& )"CC(#(@%& 4%%456-(@%& #(D4%"+@$6"G$& A"%6& )"CC(#(@%& 54#(#$;& I6(&

^'4D"%E& +C& (456& 4%%456-(@%& #(D4%"+@$6"G& & )(G(@)$& -4"@DE& +@& %6(& #($G+@$",(@($$& 4@)&

$(@$"%","%E&+C&%6(& 54#(#&LT+AD.EH&9` \0Q;&I6(&-+$%&"-G+#%4@%&C45%+#&"@&)(%(#-"@"@F&%6(&^'4D"%E&

+C&%6(&#(D4%"+@$6"G&"$&@+%&%6(&4-+'@%&+C&%"-(&$G(@%&A"%6&%6(&56"D)&+#&A6+&G#+,")($&%6(&%4$B$&

+C&54#"@FH&.'%&A6+&"@%(#45%$&A"%6&%6(&56"D)&4@)&#($G+@)$&$(@$"%",(DE&%+&%6("#&@(()$&LT+AD.EH&

9`\0Q;&&8,(#%"-(H&#(G(%"%",(&(KG(#"(@5($&A"%6"@&(4#DE&#(D4%"+@$6"G$&F(@(#4%(&A64%&"$&%(#-()&

4@&["@%(#@4D&A+#B"@F&-+)(D?&L=R3Q;&I6(&=R3&"$&%6(&"@)",")'4D?$&-(@%4D&#(G#($(@%4%"+@&+C&%6(&

A+#%6"@($$& +C& $(DC& 4@)& %6(& 4,4"D4."D"%E& +C& +%6(#$;& I6(& =R3& "$& 5(@%#4D& %+& %6(& G#+5($$& +C&

Page 6 of 13

"@%(#G#(%"@F& (KG(#"(@5($H& D(4#@"@F& C#+-& %6(& G4$%& 4@)& F'")"@F& 4@)& "@CD'(@5"@F& C'%'#(&

(KG(#"(@5(&L24"B($&N&I6+-G$+@H&/00\1&J"(F4DH&9```Q;&&&

<%%456-(@%&%6(+#E&"$&A(DD&$'GG+#%()&.E&4&D4#F(&.+)E&+C&(,")(@5(&(K4-"@"@F&%6(&4$$+5"4%"+@&

.(%A((@&(4#DE&4%%456-(@%&G4%%(#@$&4@)&D4%(#&+'%5+-($&L24"B($&N&I6+-G$+@H&/00\Q;&&R6(@&

54#(F",(#$&#($G+@)&"@&4&G#+-G%H&5+@$"$%(@%&4@)&$(@$"%",(&-4@@(#&%+&%6("#&"@C4@%?$&5#E"@FH&%6(&

"@C4@%&"$&#(4$$'#()&%64%&%6(&54#(F",(#$&4#(&4,4"D4.D(&C+#&5+-C+#%&4@)&%6(&"@C4@%&C((D$&$4C(;&R6(@&

%6($(&(KG(#"(@5($&4#(&#(G(4%()&5+@$"$%(@%DEH&%6(&"@C4@%&)(,(D+G$&4&$(5'#(&4%%456-(@%&L34#($&

(%&4D;H&/09/Q;&&O6"D)#(@&A"%6&4&$(5'#(&4%%456-(@%&64,(&4&$%#+@F&)(,(D+G-(@%4D&C+'@)4%"+@H&

A"%6& -+#(& G+$"%",(& $+5"4D& 4@)& (-+%"+@4D& +'%5+-($H& "@5D')"@F& %6(& 4."D"%E& %+& #(F'D4%(& %6("#&

(-+%"+@$H&.(%%(#&$+5"4D&5+-G(%(@5(H&4@)&4&6"F6(#&$(@$(&+C&$(DCWA+#%6&L24"B($&N&I6+-G$+@H&

/00\Q;&&

Infant&Development&

=@&%6(&C"#$%&C(A&E(4#$&+C&D"C(H&"@C4@%$&4@)&E+'@F&56"D)#(@&#(DE&4D-+$%&(@%"#(DE&+@&%6("#&54#(F",(#$&

%+& -((%& %6("#& G6E$"54D& 4@)& (-+%"+@4D& @(()$;& =@& %6(& (4#DE& -+@%6$& +C& D"C(H& '@(KGD4"@()& 4@)&

$+-(%"-($&)"CC"5'D%&%+&$++%6(&5#E"@F&(K"$%$&45#+$$&4DD&5'D%'#($&4@)&-4E&.(&$((@&%+&.(&4&G4#%&+C&

@+#-4D& )(,(D+G-(@%;& While& this& can& be& distressing& for& 54#(F",(#$,& this& natural& increase& in&

crying&peaks&at&around&six&to&eight&weeks&and&generally&settles&by&three&to&four&months&(Barr,&

1998).&There&is&great&variation&in&normal&infant&sleep&behaviour,&and&night&wakings&are&normal&

for&children&under&one&year&of&age.&&The&number&of&night&wakings&and&staying&awake&at&night&in&

infants&under&one&year&of&age&is&&not&associated&with&adverse&developmental&outcomes&(Pennestri&

et&al.,&2018).&

<%&4#+'@)&("F6%&-+@%6$H&"@C4@%$&-4E&.(F"@&%+&(KG#($$&)"$%#($$&A6(@&4&54#(F",(#&"$&4.$(@%&(,(@&

C+#& +@DE& 4& .#"(C& -+-(@%;& I6"$& [$(G4#4%"+@& 4@K"(%E?& "$& 4& @+#-4D& G4#%& +C& 4F(W4GG#+G#"4%(&

)(,(D+G-(@%&4@)&+C%(@&5+"@5")($&A"%6&%6(&"@C4@%?$&)(,(D+G-(@%&+C&[+.k(5%&G(#-4@(@5(?&A6(@&

%6(E&#(4D"$(&%64%&%6"@F$&4@)&G(+GD(&(K"$%&(,(@&A6(@&%6(E&4#(&+'%&+C&$"F6%;&=@C4@%$&-4E&5#E&4%&

%"-($&+C&$(G4#4%"+@&4$&%6(E&-4E&.(D"(,(&%64%&%6("#&54#(F",(#&64$&4.4@)+@()&%6(-&L34#($&(%&

4D;H&/09/Q;&&&J(G4#4%"+@&4@K"(%E&'$'4DDE&G(4B$&4#+'@)&97W9\&-+@%6$&+C&4F(&4@)&$(%%D($&)+A@&

.E&%A+&%+&%6#((&E(4#$&+C&4F(&A6(@&%6(& 56"D)&64$&4&5+#(&'@)(#$%4@)"@F&4@)&(@+'F6&(KG(#"(@5(&

%+&%#'$%&%6(&54#(F",(#&A"DD&#(%'#@&4@)&6(&+#&$6(&"$&$4C(&L34#($&(%&4D;H&/09/Q;&JD((G&%"-(&-4E&

#(G#($(@%&4&%"-(&+C&G(#5(",()&$(G4#4%"+@&C+#&%6(&"@C4@%;&R6(@&"@C4@%$&+#&%+))D(#$&5#E&'G+@&

$(G4#4%"+@&4%&.()%"-(&"%&"$&4&$"F@4D&%64%&%6(E&-4E&.(&$%#'FFD"@F&A"%6&%6"$&G#+5($$&4@)&@(()&

#(4$$'#4@5(;

=@C4@%$&A6+$(& 54#(F",(#$&#($G+@)& G#+-G%DE& 4@)& (-G4%6"54DDE& %+& %6("#& 5#E"@F&

D(4#@&%+&$(%%D(&4$&%6(E&.(5+-(&$(5'#(&"@&%6(&B@+AD()F(&%64%&%6("#&@(()$&C+#&(-+%"+@4D&5+-C+#%&

A"DD&.(&-(%&LT(DD&N&<"@$A+#%6H&9`P/1&>"FD(E&N&S+c"(#H&/00`Q;&

I6(#(&4#(&,4#"+'$&%"-($&"@&56"D)#(@?$&)(,(D+G-(@%&L"DD@($$H&54#(#&4.$(@5(H&-4k+#&564@F($Q&

A6(@&%6(E&@(()&-+#(&4$$"$%4@5(&A"%6&$D((G&4@)&$(%%D"@F&%64@&4%&+%6(#&%"-($;&!4-"DE&(,(@%$&

%64%&4#(&)"$%#($$"@F&C+#&%6(&"@C4@%&-4E&D(4)&%+&4&@(()&C+#&-+#(&$'GG+#%&4@)&#(4$$'#4@5(&%64@&

"@&@+@W$%#($$C'D&%"-($;&I+&)(@E&#(4$$'#4@5(&%+&%6(&"@C4@%&)'#"@F&%6($(&%"-($&"$&)"$%#($$"@F&4@)&

-4E&64,(&4&@(F4%",(&G$E56+D+F"54D&"-G45%;&LJc4D4,"%c&N&_(##EH&/090Q&

Page 7 of 13

Culture&

R6"D(& "@C4@%& $D((G& "$& D4#F(DE& 4& ."+D+F"54DDE& )#",(@& .(64,"+'#H& "%& "$& $%#+@FDE& "@CD'(@5()& 4@)&

"@%(#G#(%()& .E& %6(& 5'D%'#4D& ,4D'($& +C& %6(& 54#(F",(#$& 4@)& .#+4)(#& 5+--'@"%E& LM(@@"& N&

8UO+@@+#H&/00VQ;&&&YK%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D& $D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&64,(&%6("#&+#"F"@$&"@&@(+W

D".(#4D&R($%(#@&56"D)#(4#"@F&G#45%"5($&%64%&GD45(&4&F#(4%(#&,4D'(&+@&"@)",")'4D"$%&G4#(@%"@F&

4GG#+456($&%64%&G#+-+%(&"@)(G(@)(@5(&C#+-&4&E+'@F&4F(&LY%6(#%+@&(%&4D;H&/09X1&34'%(&N&

_(##(@H&/09\Q;& & I6($(& G#45%"5($& 4@)&.(D"(C$& $'FF($%& %64%& 4@& "@C4@%?$& 4."D"%E& %+& $(DCW$(%%D(& "$&

5(@%#4D&%+&%6("#&G#+F#($$&%+A4#)$&$(DCW#(F'D4%"+@&4@)&"@)(G(@)(@5(&L3($-4@&(%&4D;H&/09\Q;&&

I6"$&"$&$'GG+#%()&.E&%6(&C45%&%64%&%6(&D4#F(&-4k+#"%E&+C&#($(4#56&"@%+&.(64,"+'#4D&.4$()&$D((G&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$& 64$& .((@& 5+@)'5%()& "@& '#.4@& R($%(#@& G+G'D4%"+@$& L3($-4@& (%& 4D;H& /09\Q;&&

<5#+$$&)"CC(#(@%&5'D%'#($H&.(D"(C$&,4#E&4.+'%&6+AH&A6E&4@)&A6(#(&"@C4@%$&$6+'D)&$D((GH&4$&A(DD&

4$&A64%&)(C"@($& @+#-4D&$D((G&+#&4&$D((G&G#+.D(-;&&JD((G&.(64,"+'#&"$& G#+.D(-4%"5&+@DE&"@&

#(D4%"+@& %+& %6(& 54#(F",(#$& 4@)& 5+--'@"%"($& (KG(5%4%"+@$H& #4%6(#& %64@& 4& 5D(4#DE& )(C"@()&

(,")(@5(W.4$()&)(C"@"%"+@&+C&4&$D((G&G#+.D(-&LY%6(#%+@&(%&4D;H&/09XQ;&&&I6(&)(-4@)$&+C&-+)(#@&

D"C(H&564@F($&%+&C4-"DE&$%#'5%'#($&4@)&4&[56"D)&"DD"%(#4%(?&$+5"(%E&64,(&D()&%+&4@&(KG(5%4%"+@&%64%&

4DD&"@C4@%$&4@)&%+))D(#$&$6+'D)&$D(( G&%6#+'F6&%6(&@"F6%&C#+-&%6(&(4#DE&-+@%6$&+#&(,(@&A((B$;&

Bed&sharing&

T()&$64#"@F&"$&)(C"@()&4$&A6(#(&4&G4#(@%&+#&54#(#&4@)&"@C4@%&4#(&.+%6&$D((G"@F&A6"D(&$64#"@F&

4&$D((G&$'#C45(&%+F(%6(#&L3"D(,4WJ("%cH&T4B(#-4@$Wb#4@(@.'#FH&T4%%4"@"H&N&a'"kBH&/09PQ;&=@&

<'$%#4D"4H&%6(&5'##(@%&@4%"+@4D&=@C4@%&J4C(&JD((G&#(5+--(@)4%"+@$&$'FF($%&%64%&"@C4@%$&$6+'D)&

64,(&%6("#&+A@&$D((G&$G45(&"@&%6("#&G4#(@%?$&#++-&C+#&%6(&C"#$%&XW9/&-+@%6$&+C&D"C(&L2()&*+$(H&

/09\Q;&&>+A(,(#H&"@)",")'4D&$%4%(&4@)&%(##"%+#E&6(4D%6&)(G4#%-(@%$&64,(&4D$+&)(,(D+G()&%6("#&

+A@&$D"F6%DE&-+)"C"()&F'")(D"@($;&I6"$&64$&5#(4%()&"@5+@$"$%(@5"($&"@&-($$4F"@FH&($G(5"4DDE&"@&

%6(&4#(4&+C&.()&$64#"@F&A6"56&64$&4&)(,(D+G"@F&(,")(@5(&.4$(;&&2(5(@%&<'$%#4D"4@&#($(4#56&

64$&6"F6D"F6%()&%64%&%6(&"@C4@%&$D((G&G#45%"5($&+C&-4@E&C4-"D"($&5+@%#4)"5%&%6($(&F'")(D"@($;&

PP]&+C&"@C4@%$&64)&$64#()&4&$D((G&$'#C45(&A"%6&4@+%6(#&G(#$+@&4%&$+-(&%"-(H&A"%6&+,(#&V0]&

+C&C4-"D"($&"@)"54%"@F&%6"$&A4$&@+%&GD4@@()&LO+D(H&e+'@FH&b(4#@(EH&N&I6+-G$+@H&/0/0Q;&&<D$+H&

+@(&"@&C+'#&"@C4@%$&$G(@%&%A+&+#&-+#(&@"F6%$&4&A((B&$64#"@F&4&$D((G&$'#C45(&LO+D(&(%&4D;H&/0/0Q;&&

=@& /09\& 2()& *+$(H& %6(&*f8& G#"-4#"DE& #($G+@$".D(& C+#& )(,(D+G"@F& "@C4@%& $4C(& $D((G& G'.D"5&

6(4D%6& G#+F#4-$& #(D(4$()& 4& G+$"%"+@& $%4%(-(@%& +@& $64#"@F& 4& $D((G& $G45(;& I6"$& $%4%(-(@%&

$'GG+#%$& C4-"D"($& %+& -4B(& .()& $64#"@F& 4$& $4C(& 4$& G+$$".D(H& #(5+F@"$($& %6(& -4@E& .(@(C"%$&

4$$+5"4%()&A"%6&$64#"@F&4&$D((G&$G45(&"@5D')"@F&"-G#+,()&.#(4$%C(()"@F&+'%5+-($H&"-G#+,()&

-4%(#@4D&$D((G&4@)&"-G#+,()&"@C4@%&$(%%D"@F&A"%6&D($$&5#E"@F&4@)&#()'5()&$%#($$&#($G+@$(&

L2()& *+$(H& /09`Q;&&>+A(,(#H& %6"$& -($$4F(& "$& E(%& %+& .(& 5D(4#DE& #(5(",()& +#& )(D",(#()& .E&

G#+C($$"+@4D$&A+#B"@F&A"%6&C4-"D"($&4@)&"@C4@%$;&34@E&C4-"D"($&$%"DD&)+&@+%&#(5(",( &4&.4D4@5()&

)"$5+'#$(&+@&.()&$64#"@FH&)(G#","@F&%6(-&+C&%6(&4."D"%E&%+&-4B(&4@&"@C+#-()&56+"5(&C+#&%6("#&

C4-"DE&LO'@@"@F64-H&l4DDEH&N&T'F(k4H&/09\1&34#"@(DD"H&T4DDH&35b(@@4H&N&TD4"#H&/09`Q;&

Page 8 of 13

AAIMH’s position – Extinction Based Behavioral Sleep Interventions

<<=3>&"$&5+@5(#@()&%64%&(K%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&@+%&5+@$"$%(@%&

A"%6& %6(& "@C4@%?$& @(()$& C+#& +G%"-4D& (-+%"+@4D& 4@)& G$E56 +D+F"54D& 6(4D%6& 4@)& -4E& 64,(&

'@"@%(@)()&@(F4%",(&5+@$(^'(@5($;&YK%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&64,(&

@+%&.((@&#"F+#+'$DE&4$$($$()&"@&%(#-$&+C&%6(&"-G45%&+@&%6(&"@C4@%?$&(-+%"+@4D&)(,(D+G-(@%;&

R6"D(&4#F'4.DE&%6(#(&"$&(,")(@5(&%+&$'FF($%&%6($(&%(56@"^'($&)+&@+%&64#-&"@C4@%$H&%6"$&)+($&

@+%&-(4@&%6(#(&"$&(,")(@5(&+C&@+&64#-;&&&

I6($(&%EG(&+C&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&4%&+))$&A"%6&%6(&+,(#A6(D-"@F&.+)E&+C&(,")(@5(&%64%&

$6+A$&%64%&%6(&C+'@)4%"+@$&C+#&D"C(D+@F&G6E$"54D&4@)&G$E56+D+F"54D&6(4D%6&4#(&D4")&)+A@&"@&

"@C4@5E& A6(@& )"$%#($$& "$& #($G+@)()& %+& "@& 4& G#+-G%& 4@)& #(D"4.D(& A4E& L*4%"+@4D& J5"(@%"C"5&

O+'@5"D&+@&%6(&S(,(D+G"@F&O6"D)&/0/0Q;&&&

<D%6+'F6& (K%"@5%"+@& .4$()& .(64,"+'#4D& $D((G& "@%(#,(@%"+@$& -4E& #()'5(& "@C4@%& 5#E"@F& 4@)&

"@5#(4$(&54#(F",(#&G(#5(",()&"@C4@%&$D((G&%"-(H&%6(E&-4E&4D$+&64,(&%6(&'@"@%(@)()&(CC(5%&+C&

%(456"@F& "@C4@%$& @+%& %+& $((B& +#& (KG(5%& $'GG+#%& A6(@& )"$%#($$()& LTD'@)(@H& I6+-G$+@H& N&

S4A$+@H& /0991& Y%6(#%+@& (%& 4D;H& /09XQ;& <& D45B& +C& #($G+@$(& %+& "@C4@%& 5#"($& 4%& @"F6%H& 4@)& 4@&

"@5+@$"$%(@%&4GG#+456&"@&#($G+@)"@F&%+&)4E&4@)&@"F6%&)"$%#($$&$"F@4D$&-4E&D(4)&%+&"@5#(4$()&

"@C4@%&$%#($$&L_+#%(#H&/00PQ;&&&

R6(@& 5+@5(#@$& 4#(& #4"$()& .E& 54#(F",(#$& 4.+'%& $D((G"@F& )"CC"5'D%"($H& 4& C'DD& G#+C($$"+@4D&

4$$($$-(@%&$6+'D)&"@5D')(d&

• _#(F@4@5E&)(%4"D$H&."#%6&6"$%+#E&4@)&"@C4@%?$&6"$%+#E&$"@5(&."#%6&

• O4#(F",(#&4."D"%E&%+&5+G(H&"@5D')"@F&-()"54D&+#&-(@%4D&6(4D%6&5+@)"%"+@$H&)"$4."D"%"($H&)#'F&

4@)&4D5+6+D&'$(H&%"-(&5+@$%#4"@%$H&4@K"(%"($H&4$&A(DD&4$&$'GG+#%$&

• S($5#"G%"+@&+C&4&[@+#-4D?&/76#$H&"@5D')"@F&.()%"-(&#+'%"@($&4@)&$(%%D"@F&$%#4%(F"($&

• =@C4@%&C(()"@F&G#45%"5($H&"@5D')"@F&+.$(#,"@F&4&C(()&

• I6(&"@C4@%?$&$D((G&4@)&5+--'@"54%"+@&$%#4%(F"($&

• O4#(F",(#$&)(,(D+G-(@%4D&(KG(5%4%"+@$&+C&%6(&"@C4@%&4@)&G(#5(G%"+@&+C&%6(&"@C4@%&

• >+A&%6(&"@C4@%?$&$D((G&"$&4CC(5%"@F&%6(&C4-"DE&

• <@E&"@C4@%&-()"54D&+#&)(,(D+G-(@%4D&5+@5(#@$&

• <&.#"(C&$'--4#E&+C&%6(&C4-"DE&+C&+#"F"@&

• R64%&4#(&%6(&54#(F",(#?$&5+@5(#@$&4@)&A64%&)+&%6(E&A4@%&%+&564@F(m&

• R64%&64$&.((@&)+@(&4D#(4)Em&R64%&64$&+#&64$@?%&A+#B()m&

• <&.#"(C&G(#"+)&+C&54#(F",(#&W"@C4@%&+.$(#,4%"+@&

L34#($&(%&4D;H&/09/Q&

I6"$& 4$$($$-(@%& -4E& %6(@& D(4)& %+& 4& [$64#()& '@)(#$%4@)"@F?& +C& %6(& "@C4@%& 4@)& C4-"DE?$&

G(#$G(5%",(&4@)&4GG#+G#"4%(&$'GG+#%&4@)Z+#&#(C(##4D;&&

<<=3>&.(D"(,($&%6(&C+DD+A"@F&G#"@5"GD($&$6+'D)&.(&4GGD"()&%+&4DD&"@C4@%&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$d&

• &&&<@E& "@%(#,(@%"+@& '$()& %+& $'GG+#%& "@C4@%& $D((G& $6+'D)& @+%& 5+-G#+-"$(& %6(& "@C4@%?$&

)(,(D+G-(@%4D& 4@)& (-+%"+@4D& @(()$;& <& 5+-G#(6(@$",(& 4$$($$-(@%& 4$& )(%4"D()& 4.+,(&

$6+'D)&.(&5+@)'5%()&A"%6&4DD&C4-"D"($;&

• &&&=%&"$&@+#-4D&4@)&6(4D%6E&C+#&"@C4@%$&%+&A4B(&%6#+'F6&%6(&@"F6%&4@)&%+&@(()&5+@@(5%"+@&A"%6&

54#(F",(#$;&I6"$&@(()&@+%&.(&D4.(DD()&4&G#+.D(-&+#&)"$+#)(#;&I6(#(&"$&4&A")(&,4#"4%"+@&"@&

6+A&^'"5BDE&"@C4@%$&$(%%D(&4@)&[$D((G&%6#+'F6&%6(&@"F6%;?&&Y4#DE&4@)&#(4D"$%"5&"@C+#-4%"+@&

4.+'%& A64%& %+& (KG(5%& 4@)& A4E$& %+& $'GG+#%& "@C4@%$& $6+'D)& ")(4DDE& .(& 4,4"D4.D(& %+& 4DD&

54#(F",(#$&%+&6(DG&'@)(#$%4@)&%6("#&"@C4@%?$&$%4%(&+C&-"@)&4@)&4GG#+G#"4%(DE&(@F4F(&A"%6&

Page 9 of 13

%6("#& "@C4@%?$& $D((G"@F& G4%%(#@$;& I6"$& "@5D')($& $'GG+#%"@F& 54#(F",(#$& %+& 64,(& 4& $+'@)&

'@)(#$%4@)"@F&+C&%6(&)#",(#$&+C&"@C4@%&$D((GH&4@)&,4#"4%"+@&"@&@+#-4D&6(4D%6E&"@C4@%&$D((G&

G4%%(#@$;&

• &&&2(5+F@"%"+@&%64%& 54#(F",(#$&+C%(@&$%#'FFD(&%+&4)+G%&(K%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D& $D((G&

"@%(#,(@%"+@$&.(54'$(&%6(E&5+@%#4)"5%&%6("#&"@@4%(&)($"#(&%+&#($G+@)&G#+-G%DE&%+&%6("#&

"@C4@%?$&)"$%#($$H&%6("#&+A@&G4#(@%"@F&.(D"(C$H&+#&4&.(D"(C&%64%&%6(E&-4E&54'$(&%6(&"@C4@%&

64#-;&

• I6(#(&"$&#++-&C+#&6'-4@&(##+#&"@&#($G+@$",(&54#(F",(#W"@C4@%&#(D4%"+@$6"G$;&O4#(F",(#$&

)+& @+%& @(()& %+& .(& G(#C(5%1& %6(E& k'$%& @(()& %+&.(& F++)& (@+'F6;&O4#(F",(#$& A"DD&D(4#@& %+&

#($G+@)&$(@$"%",(DE&+@DE&%6#+'F6&5D+$(&+.$(#,4%"+@&+C&%6("#&"@C4@%H&4@)&%#"4D&4@)&(##+#;&

O4#(F",(#$&)+&@+%&@(()&%+&F(%&%6"$&#"F6%&4DD&%6(&%"-(;&&

• &&&2($G+@)"@F&%+&4@&"@C4@%?$&@(()$Z5#E"@F&A"DD&@+%&54'$(&)(G(@)(@5E&.'%&A"DD&5+@%#".'%(&%+&

%6(&"@C4@%?$&$(@$(&+C&$(5'#"%E&4@)&)(,(D+G"@F&#(F'D4%+#E&54G45"%E;&

• J%#4%(F"($& .4$()& +@& 4@& '@)(#$%4@)"@F& +C& %6(& "@C4@%?$& (-+%"+@4D& A+#D)& 4@)& %6("#&

5+--'@"54%"+@& $%#4%(F"($& $6+'D)& 4DA4E$& .(& )"$5'$$()& A"%6& 54#(F",(#$& 4$& G#(C(#4.D(&

+G%"+@$&%+&(K%"@5%"+@W.4$()&$%#4%(F"($;&

• <D%(#@4%",($& %+& (K%"@5%"+@W.4$()& $D((G& "@%(#,(@%"+@$& @(()& %+& .(& -4)(& -+#(& #(4)"DE&

4,4"D4.D(&%+&54#(F",(#$;&O4#(F",(#$&@(()&%+&.(&G#+,")()&A"%6&4&#4@F(&+C&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&

C#+-&4&,4#"(%E&+C&%6(+#(%"54D&G(#$G(5%",($&$+&%6(E&54@&-4B(&4@&"@C+#-()&56+"5(&.4$()&+@&

%6("#&C4-"DE?$&"@)",")'4D&5"#5'-$%4@5($;&&

• YK%"@5%"+@&.4$()&.(64,"+'#4D&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4#(&@+%&4GG#+G#"4%(&C+#&'$(&.(C+#(&%6(&

"@C4@%&64$&4&#(4D&'@)(#$%4@)"@F&+C&%6(&-(4@"@F&+C&%6(&54#(F",(#?$&A+#)$1&%6(&"@C4@%&@(()$&

%+&B@+A&%64%&%6(&54#(F",(#&A"DD&#(%'#@&4@)&@(()$&%+&C((D&$4C(&A6(@&%6(&54#(F",(#&"$&4.$(@%;&

• <<=3>& $'GG+#%$& %6(& '$(& +C& [#($G+@$",(?& .4$()& 4GG#+456($& %+& 4))#($$"@F& "@C4@%& $D((G&

5+@5(#@$;& J'56& 4GG#+456($& $6+'D)& .(& 4%%456-(@%& "@C+#-()& 4@)& %4"D+#()& %+& %6(&

)(,(D+G-(@%4D& @(()$& +C& %6(& "@)",")'4D& "@C4@%;& I6($(& 4GG#+456($& $6+'D)& .(& .4$()& +@&

'@)(#$%4@)"@FH& #(5+F@"$"@FH& 4@)& #($G+@)"@F& %+& %6(& "@C4@%?$& 5+--'@"54%"+@& 5'($& "@& 4&

$(@$"%",(&4@)&5+@$"$%(@%&-4@@(#&%64%&$'GG+#%$&%6("#&(-+%"+@4D&@(()$&4@)&)(,(D+G-(@%;&&

• O'D%'#4DDE&4GG#+G#"4%(&4@)&J=SJ&"@C+#-()&4GG#+456($&%+&5+W$D((G"@F&@(()&%+&.(&)"$5'$$()&

A"%6&54#(F",(#$&4$&G+%(@%"4D&+G%"+@$&%+&$'GG+#%&"@C4@%&$D((G&

• <<=3>&$'GG+#%$&4&5++#)"@4%()&(CC+#%&%+&)(,(D+G&%6(&(,")(@5(&.4$(&C+#&#($G+@$(W.4$()&

$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&4$&4@&4D%(#@4%",(&+G%"+@&C+#&54#(F",(#?$&5+@5(#@()&A"%6&%6("#&"@C4@%?$&

$D((G;&

• <<=3>& $'GG+#%$& .+%6& '@",(#$4D& 4@)& %(#%"4#E& D(,(D& $(#,"5(& G#+,")(#$& 64,"@F& "@5#(4$()&

(KG+$'#(H&455($$&%+H&4@)&%#4"@"@F&"@&4&#4@F(&+C&$D((G&"@%(#,(@%"+@$&%+&-((%&%6(&@(()$&+C&

"@)",")'4D&C4-"D"($;&

Page 10 of 13

Reference List:

Baills, A. (2013). Treatment of Behavioural Sleep Problems: Asking the Parents. Journal of Sleep

Disorders: Treatment and Care, 2(2), 1-7.

Barr, R. G. (1993). Normality: a clinically useless concept: the case of infant crying and colic.

Journal of Developmental and Behavioral Pediatrics.

Barr, R. G. (1998). Colic and crying syndromes in infants. Pediatrics, 102(Supplement E1), 1282-

1286.

Bell, S. M., & Ainsworth, M. D. S. (1972). Infant crying and maternal responsiveness. Child

development, 1171-1190.

Blunden, S., & Dawson, D. (2020). Behavioural sleep interventions in infants: Plan B - Combining

models of responsiveness to increase parental choice. J Paediatr Child Health, 56(5),

675-679. doi:10.1111/jpc.14818

Blunden, S., Thompson, K. R., & Dawson, D. (2011). Behavioural sleep treatments and night time

crying in infants: challenging the status quo. Sleep medicine reviews, 15(5), 327-334.

Bowlby, J. (1958). The nature of the child's tie to his mother. International journal of psycho-

analysis, 39, 350-373.

Bowlby, J. (1980). Attachment and Loss. Volume 3: Loss. New York: Basic Books.

Bryanton, J., Beck, C. T., & Montelpare, W. (2013). Postnatal parental education for optimizing

infant general health and parent-infant relationships. Cochrane Database of Systematic

Reviews(11).

Cole, R., Young, J., Kearney, L., & Thompson, J. M. (2020). Infant care practices and parent

uptake of safe sleep messages: a cross-sectional survey in Queensland, Australia. BMC

pediatrics, 20(1), 27.

Črnčec, R., Matthey, S., & Nemeth, D. (2010). Infant sleep problems and emotional health: a

review of two behavioural approaches. Journal of Reproductive and Infant Psychology,

28(1), 44-54.

Cunningham, H., Vally, H., & Bugeja, L. (2018). Bed-sharing in the first 8 weeks of life: An

Australian study. Maternal and child health journal, 22(4), 556-564.

Douglas, P., & Hill, P. (2013). Behavioral sleep interventions in the first six months of life do not

improve outcomes for mothers or infants: a systematic review. Journal of

Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 34(7), 497-507.

Douglas, P., Hill, P., & Brodribb, W. (2011). The unsettled baby: how complexity science helps.

Archives of disease in childhood, 96(9), 793-797.

Etherton, H., Blunden, S., & Hauck, Y. (2016). Discussion of extinction-based behavioral sleep

interventions for young children and reasons why parents may find them difficult.

Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, 12(11), 1535-1543.

Gilkerson, L., Burkhardt, T., Katch, L. E., & Hans, S. L. (2020). Increasing parenting self-efficacy:

The Fussy Baby Network(®) intervention. Infant Ment Health J, 41(2), 232-245.

doi:10.1002/imhj.21836

Page 11 of 13

Higley, E., & Dozier, M. (2009). Nighttime maternal responsiveness and infant attachment at one

year. Attachment & Human Development, 11(4), 347-363.

Hiscock, H., Cook, F., Bayer, J., Le, H. N., Mensah, F., Cann, W., . . . St James-Roberts, I. (2014).

Preventing early infant sleep and crying problems and postnatal depression: a

randomized trial. Pediatrics, 133(2), e346-e354.

Hiscock, H., & Davey, M. J. (2018). Sleep disorders in infants and children. Journal of paediatrics

and child health, 54(9), 941-944.

James-Roberts, I. S. (2007). Helping parents to manage infant crying and sleeping: a review of

the evidence and its implications for services. Child Abuse Review: Journal of the British

Association for the Study and Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, 16(1), 47-69.

Jenni, O. G., & Carskadon, M. A. (2007). Sleep behavior and sleep regulation from infancy

through adolescence: normative aspects. Sleep medicine clinics, 2(3), 321-329.

Jenni, O. G., & O'Connor, B. B. (2005). Children's sleep: an interplay between culture and

biology. Pediatrics, 115(Supplement 1), 204-216.

Kempler, L., Sharpe, L., Miller, C. B., & Bartlett, D. J. (2016). Do psychosocial sleep interventions

improve infant sleep or maternal mood in the postnatal period? A systematic review

and meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 29, 15-22.

Mares, S., Newman, L., & Warren, B. (2012). Clinical skills in infant mental health: The first three

years 2nd Edn. Melbourne: ACER Press.

Marinelli, K. A., Ball, H. L., McKenna, J. J., & Blair, P. S. (2019). An integrated analysis of maternal-

infant sleep, breastfeeding, and sudden infant death syndrome research supporting a

balanced discourse. Journal of Human Lactation, 35(3), 510-520.

Maute, M., & Perren, S. (2018). Ignoring Children's Bedtime Crying: The Power of Western-

Oriented Beliefs. Infant mental health journal, 39(2), 220-230.

Mesman, J., Minter, T., Angnged, A., Cissé, I. A., Salali, G. D., & Migliano, A. B. (2018).

Universality without uniformity: A culturally inclusive approach to sensitive

responsiveness in infant caregiving. Child Development, 89(3), 837-850.

Middlemiss, W. (2013). Sleep Training Not Harmful? Methodological concerns question

conclusion. Commentry on Five-Year Follow-up of Harms and Benefits of Behavioral

Infant Sleep Intervention: Randomized Trial. Retrieved from

https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/130/4/643/tab-e-letters

Middlemiss, W., Granger, D. A., Goldberg, W. A., & Nathans, L. (2012). Asynchrony of mother–

infant hypothalamic–pituitary–adrenal axis activity following extinction of infant crying

responses induced during the transition to sleep. Early human development, 88(4), 227-

232.

Middlemiss, W., Stevens, H., Ridgway, L., McDonald, S., & Koussa, M. (2017). Response-based

sleep intervention: Helping infants sleep without making them cry. Early Human

Development, 108, 49-57.

Mihelic, M., Morawska, A., & Filus, A. (2017). Effects of early parenting interventions on parents

and infants: A meta-analytic review. Journal of Child and Family Studies, 26(6), 1507-

1526.

Page 12 of 13

Mileva-Seitz, V. R., Bakermans-Kranenburg, M. J., Battaini, C., & Luijk, M. P. (2017). Parent-child

bed-sharing: the good, the bad, and the burden of evidence. Sleep Medicine Reviews,

32, 4-27.

Mindell, J., Kuhn, B., Lewin, D., Meltzer, L., & Sadeh, A. (2006). Behavioral treatment of bedtime

problems and night wakings in infants and young children. Sleep, 29(10), 1263-1276.

National Scientific Council on the Developing Child (2020). Connecting the Brain to the Rest of

the Body: Early Childhood Development and Lifelong Health Are Deeply Intertwined

Working Paper No. 15. National Academies Press

Paavonen, E. J., Saarenpää-Heikkilä, O., Morales-Munoz, I., Virta, M., Häkälä, N., Pölkki, P., . . .

Karlsson, L. (2020). Normal sleep development in infants: findings from two large birth

cohorts. Sleep Medicine, 69, 145-154.

Pennestri, M.-H., Laganière, C., Bouvette-Turcot, A.-A., Pokhvisneva, I., Steiner, M., Meaney, M.

J., . . . Team, M. R. (2018). Uninterrupted infant sleep, development, and maternal

mood. Pediatrics, 142(6).

Porter, L. (2007). All night long: understanding the world of infant sleep. Breastfeeding Review,

15(3), 11.

Price, A. M., Brown, J. E., Bittman, M., Wake, M., Quach, J., & Hiscock, H. (2014). Children's sleep

patterns from 0 to 9 years: Australian population longitudinal study. Archives of Disease

in Childhood, 99(2), 119-125.

Price, A. M., Wake, M., Ukoumunne, O. C., & Hiscock, H. (2012). Outcomes at six years of age for

children with infant sleep problems: longitudinal community-based study. Sleep

Medicine, 13(8), 991-998.

Raikes, H. A., & Thompson, R. A. (2008). Attachment security and parenting quality predict

children's problem-solving, attributions, and loneliness with peers. Attachment &

human development, 10(3), 319-344.

Ramos, K. D., & Youngclarke, D. M. (2006). Parenting advice books about child sleep: cosleeping

and crying it out. Sleep, 29(12), 1616-1623.

Red Nose. (2018). What is a safe sleeping environment? Retrieved from

https://rednose.org.au/article/what-is-a-safe-sleeping-environment

Red Nose. (2019). Safe Sleeping: Sharing a Sleep Surface with a Baby. Retrieved from

https://rednose.org.au/downloads/InfoStatement_SharingSleepSurfacewithBaby_Dec2

019.pdf

Sadeh, A., Mindell, J. A., Luedtke, K., & Wiegand, B. (2009). Sleep and sleep ecology in the first 3

years: a web-based study. Journal of sleep research, 18(1), 60-73.

Siegal, D. (1999). The Developing Mind. New York: Guildford Press.

Skinner, B. (1984). The evolution of behavior. Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior,

41(2), 217-221. doi:10.1901/jeab.1984.41-217

Sroufe, L., Egeland, B., Carlson, E., & Collins, A. (2005). Placing Early Attachment Expereinces in

Developmental Context: the Minnesota Longitudinal Study. In K. Grossmann & E. Waters

(Eds.), Attachment from Infancy to Adulthood: the major longitudunal studies (pp. 48-

71). New York: Guildford Press.

Page 13 of 13

Szalavitz, M., & Perry, B. (2010). Born for love: Why empathy is essential and endangered. New

York: William Morrow.

Teti, D. M., Kim, B.-R., Mayer, G., & Countermine, M. (2010). Maternal emotional availability at

bedtime predicts infant sleep quality. Journal of Family Psychology, 24(3), 307.

Tse, L., & Hall, W. (2008). A qualitative study of parents' perceptions of a behavioural sleep

intervention. Child: care, health and development, 34(2), 162-172.

Whittingham, K., & Douglas, P. (2014). Optimizing parent–infant sleep from birth to 6 months: a

new paradigm. Infant mental health journal, 35(6), 614-623.

Zeanah, C., & Boris, W. (2000). Disturbances and Disorders of Attachment in Early Childhood. In

C. Zeanah (Ed.), Handbook of Infant Mental Health (2nd edn.). New York: The Guilford

Press.